1999 – Luis Sanchez – Kent State University
2000 – Greg Ruffing – Kent State University
2001 – David Distelhorst – Ohio University
2002 – James Patterson – Ohio University
2003 – Haraz Ghanbari – Kent State University
2004 – Samantha Reinders – Ohio University
2005 – Katie Falkenberg – Ohio University
2006 – David Foster – Kent State University
2007 – David Foster – Kent State University
2008 – Diego James Robles – Ohio University